Do You Avoid Hard Conversations? Why Leaders Hold Back, and How to Step Forward

Published by:
Ryan Gottfredson
November 9, 2026

2 min read

Subscribe to my newsletter

Accelerate your vertical development journey. Includes cutting-edge vertical development articles, tips, and resources.

By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.

Share:

Is there a conversation you have been avoiding? One you know would make a difference in your work, in your team, and in its culture?

If so, you are in good company. One executive I recently interviewed told me about a leader on her team who wasn’t working out. She let that leader go in month ten. Looking back, she said she should have acted in month three or four.

In my recent conversations with 11 HR, talent, and leadership-development professionals, avoiding difficult conversations came up repeatedly. They described it as consuming time, delaying progress, and pulling HR into issues that leaders should be addressing themselves.

The two costs

Every hard conversation carries two costs: the cost of having it and the cost of not having it.

The cost of having it is immediate and obvious: discomfort. The conversation may be awkward. Emotions may run high. The relationship may feel strained for a while.

The cost of not having it is harder to see, because it rarely shows up in tangible ways. It bleeds out slowly. We put up with frustration. Work moves slower. The team watches what we tolerate and adjusts its standards accordingly. Over time, the problem becomes part of the team’s culture.

So the two costs differ in timing. Having the conversation costs us in the short term and, if we do it well, creates long-term value. Avoiding it spares us short-term discomfort and costs us in the long term.

When we avoid hard conversations, we trade our team’s future for our own present comfort.

Why we avoid them

When leaders struggle with hard conversations, two different questions are worth asking.

First: Have we created the right setting for these conversations? When expectations and boundaries are unclear, a hard conversation can feel unfair or arbitrary, because there is no agreed standard to point to.

Second: Do we have the capability to have them? This is the crux of the matter.

When we avoid hard conversations, it is a signal that we are wired for self-protection. When a hard conversation looms, our body registers it as a threat to something (e.g., not being liked, not belonging, offending others) and pulls us toward avoiding the immediate discomfort, even at a long-term expense.

When viewed from this lens of operating from a place of self-protection or a place of value creation, we can see that our struggles here are a signal of our leadership capability.

  • Leaders with lower capability are more wired for self-protection, they tend to lean toward short-term self-protection over long-term value creation.
  • Leaders with higher capability are more wired for value creation, they are willing to step into short-term discomfort in pursuit of long-term value creation.

But, we also have to consider how leaders handle these conversations. And, we can pull some powerful insights when we explore what gear they operate in.

Three gears, three approaches

4th Gear leaders tend to avoid direct and hard conversations. These leaders are team players, wired to fit in and belong. Their fears are self-protective: they worry they will offend someone, damage a relationship, or make a mess. Many have people-pleasing tendencies. So the conversation gets postponed, softened until it says nothing, or skipped.

5th Gear leaders are generally willing to have direct and hard conversations, but bluntly. They want to move quickly toward results and outcomes, so they don’t shy away. And, when having these conversations, they are generally more concerned with the outcome than with the person. They may get compliance but leave a bruised relationship behind.

6th Gear leaders have them for a different reason. They care about the person, and they care about the broader team and its purpose. They recognize that putting up with someone’s poor behavior affects not only them as the leader, but the whole team and its culture. And they can hold care for the person and a firm standard at the same time.

“Love ’em up”

Alan Mulally, who led Ford’s turnaround, is one of the best examples of a 6th Gear leader I know. In one of my conversations with him, he told me that he doesn’t use the word “accountability.” That caught me off guard. How does the CEO of a major automaker not use the word accountability?

He explained that he didn’t disagree with the concept, just the word. He preferred another phrase: “love ’em up.”

That didn’t mean Alan avoided hard lines. He told me about a meeting in which one executive nearly came across the table at another. After the meeting, Alan went to that executive’s office. He made clear that this couldn’t continue. If the executive chose to keep operating that way, they were telling him they weren’t a good fit, and he would help them find a place that was. But if they wanted to stay, they needed to change how they operated.

That is a hard conversation. Alan had it out of care for the executive and for the team around the table.

How to step into hard conversations

Start with the setting. Ask yourself: Have I set clear expectations? If not, that is your first step. Set clear expectations and boundaries with your team, and make sure they are clearly communicated and understood. A hard conversation is far easier when you can point to a shared standard.

Then look inward. Think of a conversation you have been avoiding and ask: What am I protecting? Being liked? Keeping the peace? Avoiding a mess?

Over time, work on widening your window of tolerance. Explore what you are worried about, what pain you expect if you have the conversation, and what that says about your own insecurities. As these patterns become clearer, the discomfort loses some of its grip, and your capacity to step into it grows.

For a helpful perspective, I recommend Clair Canfield’s TEDx talk, “The Beauty of Conflict.”

If you want to work on this

If you are a leader who wants to work on this, what I have described here comes up often with my coaching clients in my Becoming Better Coaching Program. I am now taking enrollments for 2027. I only offer the program once a year, so this is a unique opportunity to develop yourself vertically and build a greater capacity to have the conversations that matter. Learn more here.

If you are an HR or L&D leader seeing this across your organization, let’s talk. We can explore bringing programming to your leaders, or having them join the coaching program. This past year, an entire leadership team went through the program together, and several of its members chose direct conversations as their area to focus on.

Subscribe to
Vertical Development Weekly

Get weekly insights on vertical development and mindset mastery. Sign up now and receive my top five articles to jumpstart your leadership growth.

Subscribe to Vertical Development Weekly Get weekly insights on vertical development and mindset mastery. Sign up now and receive my top five articles to jumpstart your leadership growth.